ARTHUR T. KOVER STEPHEN M. GOLDBERG AND BILL L. WAYNE
CREATIVITY OR EFFECTIVENESS?
A GREAT INTEGRATING CATEGORY FOR ADVERTISING
In several agencies, marketing creativity and effectiveness appear almost antipathetic. This analysis explores consumers' emotional reactions to help define advertising regarded as both creative and successful. In doing this, the article also increases questions about some standard individual procedures of advertising and marketing response, selecting in addition intended for measures of emotional response.
ARTHUR J. KOVER
Teacher Ford pork University
STEPHEN M. G Um L M B E R G Associate Teacher Fordham College or university
ithin the advertising market, there seems to become a never-ending struggle between people who create the advertising (" creatives" ) and those advertising managers who have insist which it be " effective. " Advertising firms exist, at times precariously, in unstable surroundings (Comanor ainsi que a m, 1981; Hirschman, 1989). Consequently , stability in both corporation and result generally are preferred whenever feasible by organization management. Management's goal should be to have secure output which can be predictable and " successful. " Performance, however , has many different measurements by which it is usually measured (Cook and Kover, forthcoming); the real key element can be some trusted measurement upon We give thanks to the comments and suggestions of Douglas Stayman, Joseph Priester, and specifically Bill Wells. Joseph Sirgy generously suggested a number of options for personality! enhancement. This research was supported by a grant through the Research Committee, Graduate School of Organization, Fordham University and a supplementary grant by Young & Rubicam, New York. Dom Rossi, then Director of Anteriormente, New York, offered permission pertaining to the Company to prepare edited and branded videotapes with no cost. The thanks to almost all.
WILLIAM T, JAMES
Teacher Hofsira University
which agency management and clients may concur. Usually, that dimension is an aspect of marketing or (ideally) marketplace sales. Creatives, alternatively, typically deride the criteria utilized by management and clients and allege they have Httle related to the way marketing really works. In a typical company structure, the advertising system is formed by simply people in the " innovative department. " Creative people (copywriters and art directors) beheve that creativity is essential for efficiency, that the imaginative element pushes the message into viewers' minds. In fact , some even feel that creativity is effectiveness (Kover, 1995). This belief seems general irrespective of a few creative people who think that creativity is just a entrance for self-indulgent " artistic" attempts (Bensman and Gerver, 1958; Ordahl, 1993). Therefore , as could possibly be expected, many agency managers mistrust imaginative advertising. Creative imagination as identified by " the creatives" can be bothersome, costly, and timeconsuming. Innovative advertising may win prizes but may have no to do with promoting effectiveness (Gaylord, 1994). Imagination, after all, can be unpredictable
Jojrnal of ADVERTISING RESEARCHвЂ”NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 199S
and can disappointed the appearance of steadiness and predictability that smoothes the lives of bureaucracies (Martin, 1994). The difference between " effectiveness" and " creativity" is structural, reflecting distinct goals and desires of different departments (Ibarra, 1992). The determination behind this research was going to see if this distinction, an artifact of advertising organization structure, could continue to exist when consumers had been exposed to the advertising. May, in fact , the several " language games" (Wittgenstein, 1953) of creativity or perhaps effectiveness end up being joined with a new language that transcends both? How do customers react to different types of advertising executions? Do that they respond since those inside the advertising business believe they will? Or is there another dimensions of response that transcends and might contain creativity and effectiveness since defined by simply...
References: E F F E C T My spouse and i V E N Elizabeth S S i9000?
ety. " Social Challenges 6, two (1958): 4-10
5(1991): 11-21. Sirgy, Meters. Joseph. " Self-Concept in Consumer Habit: A Critical
Assessment. " Record of Buyer Research being unfaithful, 3 (1982): 287-300
Convention. Durham, NC: Marketing Research Institute, 1991.